Comparison of ISO 45001:2018 with other Health and Safety Management Systems

Ensuring the health and safety of employees is a top priority for organizations across various industries. To achieve this, many companies implement health and safety management systems (HSMS) to identify and mitigate risks in the workplace. One widely recognized and implemented HSMS is the ISO 45001:2018 standard. In this blog, we will compare ISO 45001:2018 with other commonly used health and safety management systems, highlighting their similarities, differences, and benefits.

1. OHSAS 18001:2007:

   
   

   
   ISO 45001:2018 is the successor to OHSAS 18001:2007, and it incorporates many of the same principles and requirements. However, ISO 45001:2018 takes a more proactive approach to health and safety management by emphasizing risk-based thinking, leadership involvement, and stakeholder engagement. It also aligns with the High-Level Structure (HLS) framework used in other ISO management system standards, making it easier to integrate with other systems.

   
   

2. ANSI/AIHA Z10:

   
   

   
   The ANSI/AIHA Z10 standard is an American National Standard for occupational health and safety management systems. While it shares similarities with ISO 45001:2018 in terms of overall structure and objectives, there are some notable differences. ISO 45001:2018 places more emphasis on worker participation and consultation, risk assessment and management, and continual improvement. It also offers a more globally recognized framework for organizations operating internationally.

   
   

3. BS 8800:

   
   

   
   BS 8800 is a British standard for occupational health and safety management systems. Like ISO 45001:2018, it focuses on risk management, worker involvement, and continual improvement. However, ISO 45001:2018 offers a more systematic and structured approach, providing organizations with a clear framework for implementation and certification. It also aligns with other ISO standards, facilitating integration with other management systems.

   
   

4. VPP (Voluntary Protection Programs):

   
   
   
   VPP is a voluntary program administered by the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) in the United States. While it differs from ISO 45001:2018 in terms of certification process and requirements, both aim to create safer work environments. VPP focuses on recognizing and partnering with exemplary employers who have implemented effective safety and health management systems. ISO 45001:2018, on the other hand, offers a globally recognized standard applicable to organizations of all sizes and industries.

   
   

5. Six Sigma:

   
   
   

   Six Sigma is a data-driven methodology used to improve processes and reduce defects. Although it is not an HSMS like ISO 45001:2018, it can complement the implementation of ISO 45001:2018 by providing a structured problem-solving approach and measurement techniques. Six Sigma can be used to identify and analyze safety-related risks, monitor performance metrics, and drive continual improvement efforts within an organization.

   
   

6. ILO-OSH Guidelines:

   

   Image Courtesy: Wikipedia

   The International Labour Organization's Occupational Safety and Health (ILO-OSH) guidelines provide practical guidance on implementing and managing OSH systems. While ISO 45001:2018 incorporates many of the ILO-OSH principles, it goes beyond guidance by offering a comprehensive management system standard. ISO 45001:2018 provides a more robust framework, focusing on leadership commitment, worker involvement, and continual improvement, enabling organizations to effectively manage occupational health and safety risks.

In summary, while there are several health and safety management systems available, ISO 45001:2018 stands out as a comprehensive and globally recognized standard. Its emphasis on risk-based thinking, worker participation, and continual improvement makes it a powerful tool for organizations seeking to prioritize employee health and safety. By aligning with the High-Level Structure and integrating with other ISO management system standards, ISO 45001:2018 provides a consistent and harmonized approach to health and safety management. Regardless of the system chosen, organizations should carefully evaluate their specific needs, industry requirements, and global recognition when selecting an HSMS that best fits their operations and objectives.